I’ve got a fantastic recipe for you today! If you’re looking for a little homey comfort that won’t blow the ole’ calorie budget, you’ve got to try my Weeknight Mac and Cheese! With a few smart substitutions and sneaky tweaks, you can enjoy this childhood favorite for just a fraction of the calories. Super creamy and cheesy, I think your whole family will love it–mine certainly did!

Who doesn’t love macaroni and cheese? Perfectly cooked elbow pasta covered with thick and gooey cheese sauce–the epitome of comfort food! It’s warm and satisfying and can please even your pickiest eater, but with some recipes pushing upwards of 1000 calories per serving (!), mac and cheese isn’t exactly waistline friendly.

Refusing to relegate mac and cheese to special occasions only, I wanted to come up with a recipe that I could feel good serving to my family any night of the week. A mac that makes for the perfect side but with enough nutritional heft to stand alone as a cozy and satisfying lunch. And perhaps most importantly, a recipe that my whole crew would LOVE.

Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. This means I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you when you shop using these links, which helps to make this blog possible. Thank you for your support!

Making a Lighter Mac and Cheese

There’s a reason most people think of macaroni and cheese as pure indulgence. Half and half, butter, loads of cheese, pasta–need I go on? One bite of that gooey goodness and we all know what we’re dealing with! Would it be possible to give this childhood favorite a nutrition makeover?

With my work cut out for me, I set out to do just that. I wanted to create a recipe for mac that would still be wonderfully creamy and cheesy, but fit for regular rotation at the dinner table. Furthermore, I didn’t really want to get into any weird ingredients or substitutions that would be hard to find. After all, much of the beauty of a good mac and cheese is its unfussy simplicity.

So here are the little swaps and tweaks I made for my own rendition of Weeknight Mac and Cheese. After a bit of trial and error, I think I’ve come up with something your whole family is going to love!

Evaporated Milk

Many recipes for macaroni and cheese begin with a bechamel, or thickened milk sauce, as a base that will ultimately become the cheese sauce. Using low-fat evaporated milk in place of half and half or regular milk is the perfect solution for a lighter mac and cheese for a couple different reasons.

Because it’s evaporated an has less water content, evaporated milk offers a creamier mouth-feel than regular milk. Definitely a plus when you’re cutting out fat but don’t want to lose that rich consistency!

The second reason evaporated milk is so good is that it’s a little more temperature stable and therefore less likely to give you grief. Where an unwatched milk-based sauce will occasionally break on you, evaporated milk is a little more forgiving. With a house full of kids and distractions, I’m all for more forgiving!

Watch the Butter

Many recipes for mac and cheese use several tablespoons of butter. Given that each tablespoon packs 100 calories and 12 grams of fat, I knew that every little bit I could cut out would have a big impact on my calorie count.

Because my primary reason for using butter has everything to do with the roux–the fat and flour mixture that thickens the milk sauce–it was important to use enough to get the job done. This is where using the evaporated milk makes a big difference!

By using the evaporated milk, I was able to get away with using just 1 tablespoon of butter and still come away with a sauce base that’s creamy and has good body to it. No need for several tablespoons!

Good Cheese, Just Less

While I could have gone with a reduced-fat cheese, I decided instead to reach for a good quality, aged cheddar and simply cut down on the amount. Though low-fat options can be tempting when you’re trying to lighten up a recipe, many simply do not melt well, making for a rubbery mess.

I’m a big fan of Tillamook products, especially their cheeses. Tillamook’s Medium-Cheddar Cheese is aged for over 60 days, has wonderful flavor, and melts beautifully. But if you have another brand you love, go for it!

With a great cheddar cheese and a bit of mozzarella thrown in for creaminess, the end result is a deceptively rich sauce with a fraction of the calories.

Sneaking in the Good Stuff

One super easy swap to sneak in a little more nutritional value to your mac is to replace your regular elbow macaroni with a whole grain or higher protein option.

I particularly love Barilla’s Protein+ pasta. Not only is it made with several whole grains and legumes for added fiber, vitamins, and minerals, but it boasts a whopping 10 grams of protein per serving. There are several shapes to choose from–including elbows–and my crew has never noticed a difference. I’d call that a win!

Weeknight Mac and Cheese

With these smart substitutions, I wouldn’t think twice about serving up hot bowls of mac and cheese to my boys for lunch or a making a quick batch to go with dinner. It’s comfort food you can feel good about and no one will even suspect it isn’t the full monty. Your family’s going to love it!

Did you try this recipe for Weeknight Mac and Cheese? Let me know how it went down in the comments!

Psst…Hungry for more? Check out more of my delicious recipes HERE!